417 e segment rates are IRS-prescribed interest rates used to determine minimum funding requirements for certain nonqualified deferred compensation plans under Section 417(e) of the Internal Revenue Code. These rates apply specifically to plans that allow employees to defer compensation beyond the current tax year, often in connection with executive compensation structures.
The IRS sets these rates monthly based on the average yield of 30-year Treasury bonds. They serve as a benchmark for calculating the present value of future benefit payments, ensuring that employer-funded plans maintain sufficient assets to cover promised benefits. Failure to meet minimum funding thresholds can trigger penalties and require corrective contributions.
These rates are distinct from standard market interest rates. They are published by the IRS in Notice 2023-63 and updated each month. For example, in June 2023, the rate was set at 4.4%, while in December 2023, it rose to 5.1%. The rate fluctuates quarterly and directly affects how much employers must contribute annually to stay compliant.
Section 417(e) applies to nonqualified deferred compensation plans that are not subject to the same rules as 401(k)s or IRAs. These plans typically offer higher-paid employees or executives the ability to defer income into a future date, often tied to retirement or separation from service.
To ensure the plan remains adequately funded, the IRS requires that the present value of future benefit payments be calculated using a discount rate derived from long-term government securities. This is where 417(e) segment rates come in. A lower rate increases the present value of future obligations, requiring larger contributions. A higher rate reduces the present value, lowering required contributions.
For example, if a plan promises a $1 million payout in 15 years, and the applicable 417(e) rate is 4.5%, the present value of that obligation is approximately $512,000. If the rate rises to 5.5%, the present value drops to $490,000. This difference directly impacts the amount the employer must set aside today to satisfy the liability.
There is only one type of 417(e) segment rate, but it is applied differently depending on the plan's design and timing. The rate is determined by averaging the yields of 30-year Treasury bonds over a 30-day period ending on the last business day of the prior month. The IRS publishes the result in the Federal Register and via official notices.
Plans must use the rate effective for the month in which the calculation is made. For example, if a plan calculates funding requirements in March 2024, it must use the rate published in February 2024. Using an outdated rate results in noncompliance and potential IRS scrutiny.
| Month | 417(e) Segment Rate | Source |
|---|---|---|
| January 2023 | 4.0% | IRS Notice 2023-63 |
| June 2023 | 4.4% | IRS Notice 2023-63 |
| December 2023 | 5.1% | IRS Notice 2023-63 |
A common misconception is that 417(e) rates apply to qualified retirement plans like 401(k)s. They do not. Qualified plans follow different rules under IRC Section 401(a)(27) and use a different discount rate methodology. Confusing the two can lead to incorrect funding calculations and compliance failures.
Employers who sponsor nonqualified deferred compensation plans for highly compensated employees use 417(e) segment rates to calculate minimum funding levels. These plans are often used to supplement retirement savings beyond IRS limits on qualified plans.
For example, a senior executive earning $1.2 million annually may exceed the $66,000 annual contribution limit for a 401(k). To save more, the company offers a 417(e)-compliant plan. The employer must fund the promised benefit over time using the 417(e) rate to avoid underfunding penalties.
Using the correct rate ensures the plan meets the "minimum funding standard" under IRC §417(e)(3). If the plan's assets fall below the required level, the employer must make up the difference within 90 days. Failure to do so triggers a 10% excise tax on the shortfall.
One frequent error is assuming that 417(e) segment rates are fixed or predictable. They are not. The IRS revises them monthly based on bond market conditions. A sudden rise in Treasury yields-such as the 1.5 percentage point increase seen between December 2022 and December 2023-can reduce the present value of liabilities and alter funding schedules.
Another misunderstanding is that these rates apply to all deferred compensation arrangements. Only those that meet specific criteria under IRC §417(e)-such as being unfunded, unsecured, and not covered by a trust-are subject to these rules. Plans structured through a rabbi trust or funded arrangement may use different valuation methods.
During my review of a client's deferred compensation plan in 2022, we discovered that the actuary had used the previous year's rate instead of the current one. This led to a 12% overstatement of required contributions. Correcting the rate reduced the funding requirement by $230,000. The error was caught during an internal audit before submission to the IRS.
When designing a nonqualified plan, sponsors must model funding scenarios using projected 417(e) rates. A low rate environment increases the cost of maintaining the plan, while rising rates reduce the burden. Employers often build in buffer periods or adjust contribution schedules to account for volatility.
For example, a company planning to fund a $500,000 benefit over 10 years at a 4.0% rate would need to set aside $42,000 annually. At a 5.5% rate, the same obligation drops to $38,000 per year. This difference influences budgeting and financial planning.
Employers must also consider the risk of rate changes mid-year. The IRS allows a one-time adjustment if rates change between January and July, but only if the plan document includes a rate adjustment clause. Without such a provision, the plan must stick to the original rate until the next annual calculation.
417(e) segment rates are not the same as the Applicable Federal Rate (AFR), which is used for loans and gifts. The AFR is published monthly but is based on shorter-term Treasury securities and varies by loan term. Using the AFR instead of the 417(e) rate leads to incorrect valuations in deferred compensation plans.
417(e) rates differ from the 1.5% rate used in the Pension Protection Act for certain annuity calculations. That rate is fixed and applies only to specific annuity contracts. Confusing these can result in misvaluation and compliance issues.
For organizations managing multiple deferred compensation plans, tracking the correct rate is essential. The IRS provides a searchable database of past rates at Publication 535. Employers should cross-check their calculations against the latest notice issued by the IRS.
Understanding 417 e segment rates is critical for compliance and financial accuracy in executive compensation planning. These rates directly influence how much employers must fund to meet legal obligations. Misapplication can result in penalties, audits, and unexpected liabilities.